@Krumple,
Krumple;146050 wrote:I was only joking. I noticed how you get on these little kicks of yours. The most recent is this trinity and triangle thing you keep thinking you are seeing. Convincing yourself that it is present everywhere.
I'm sorry that that's the way you perceive me. If I were to play that same game, I could. Couldn't you be accused of playing a sort of bitter masochistic role ? As in you don't want to find structure or meaning, because meaninglessness is the structure you prefer? The triangle is just a pretty shape that symbolizes a philosophical point. On the other hand, trigonometric functions are indeed all over the place. Sine ways, the basic constituent of sound. I know you know some science, so certainly you are aware that our environment is structured. And surely you know that geometry has been extremely useful. So what gives? I don't see how you can accuse me of presenting some false god, just because I'm enthusiastic about the structure we humans can find/create.....
And it amuses me to find a workable interpretation of the trinity. Of course it has zero supernatural meaning for me, as I have already repeated that for me only man is god, and that both "god" and "man" are just abstractions, concepts, forms.
---------- Post added 04-12-2010 at 05:12 PM ----------
Krumple;146050 wrote:
Your little trinity thing is that way because you WANT to see it in those terms. I can point out on several explanations of yours that you are leaving out other aspects. Instead I went with the bottle of alcohol joke as to sober you up.
I see what you mean, and there is some truth in that. But let's apply that statement against itself. You think I only see what I WANT to see, because you WANT to see things like that. This presents your own cynicism as a self-indulgence. And why should a happy human being making conversation on a forum need sobering up? Am I really the problem? All I want is free time to study, walk in the sun, hug my little wife. I'm no saint, but then I don't ask much. And I also have little need for alcohol. I will confess an addiction to coffee.
---------- Post added 04-12-2010 at 05:18 PM ----------
Krumple;146050 wrote:
We fill ourselves with fiction on a daily basis yet we somehow can make the distinction between what is real and what is not, in some cases. When you are watching a movie, it can have and impact on you emotionally, yet you know it is not real. I feel that religious spirituality is just another one of these things we mistake for substantial when it is just an illusion causing an emotional response similar to a movie.
Sure, I agree with much of this. But how do we distinguish? Is unbiased thought even possible?
I won't even deny that feeling is the justification of logic. And math. At the root level, we have certain intuitional responses to certain forms. A = A is an intuition. We don't prove it because we don't need to. And the happy man who relates his happiness to a form simply shares that form, and lets the form do what it can to make his friend happy. I'll be the first to admit that there is no ideal proof.
We bow to science because it accomplishes "miracles." It allows us to fly, to talk to people on the other side of the Earth. For someone who doesn't conceive of "Nature" (a sublime abstraction) as structured both temporally and spatially, both of these feats would be indistinguishable from miracles.
95 percent if not more do not know how their technology works, not beyond the most rudimentary level. So they mumble the word science. And yet they get the essence, that this is not miracle but ingenuity working upon the obscure structure of that which is. Still, is not this obscure structure amazing? strange ? terrible? Beautiful? Spinoza could see it as God. Call it what you will. Life is passing strange, and yet sometimes boring somehow....