Thu 3 Dec, 2009 08:27 pm - Ell if you suppose the software doesn't change then that shows that it's the same software, so there would be no point in arguing. If I say :
suppose the soul doesn't change.... (view)
Thu 3 Dec, 2009 07:29 pm - yes that is the assignment, but it all has to do with psychological continuity. i am having trouble coming up with a proposal, and if i were to use that one, i would have to prove how its the same... (view)
Thu 3 Dec, 2009 07:14 pm - well the problem that i am having is trying to come up with some sort of proposal that can somehow bring the possibility of life after death... i (view)
Thu 3 Dec, 2009 05:14 pm - how you could still recognize a person by their behavior, which says they must be the same person because of that. i feel like it is the same as psychological characteristics. (view)
Thu 3 Dec, 2009 05:01 pm - this is diffucult for me to formulate. i tried to say the behavior of people but that seems like it is exactly like the psychological characteristics of a person, unless i can somehow distinguish... (view)
Thu 3 Dec, 2009 02:54 pm - [QUOTE=kennethamy;107886]Don't you mean, same body=same person? The soul is what is sometimes called, "an intermediate variable", and can be dropped, since you are going to use... (view)
Thu 3 Dec, 2009 02:17 pm - [QUOTE=kennethamy;107859]Locke's proposal was the criterion of memory. But that has its problems too. How do you tell you are remembering correctly? It seems to me that X and Y are one and the... (view)
Thu 3 Dec, 2009 12:08 pm - [QUOTE=kennethamy;107772]If you mean by "making the proposal stronger" that you have to give a way of deciding whether A and B have to same soul in order to decide whether A and B are the... (view)
Thu 3 Dec, 2009 02:06 am - [QUOTE=kennethamy;107769]If the criterion for "same person" is, "same soul", but if there is no criterion for, "same soul", then, of course, the "same soul"... (view)
Thu 3 Dec, 2009 01:35 am - i am going to reference to a different webpage so you can get a better understanding of what i am talking about.
[url=http://www.jimpryor.net/teaching/courses/intro/notes/perry1.html]V83.0010... (view)
