@Gnostic,
Emil wrote:Don't you mean to say that it does express a proposition but the proposition is false because there is no Mickey Mouse?
Hm, I don't know. That there is no Mickey Mouse means that there is no proposition being made, doesn't it? Sentences regarding things of fiction, express propositions?
Quote:Yes, it does. It's called a conjunction. I have no idea how you got the idea that if a sentence contains an "and" with the conjunction meaning, it really does not express a conjunction but instead expresses two simple proposotions. Do you think that one cannot express conjunctions? That would seem to follow from what you wrote, and it is untenable. What a waste of time for logicians when they invented truth tables for conjunctions and stuff. Poor De Morgan!
It doesn't make any sense to me to say that it is a single proposition in a compound sentence.
I interpret:
"The chemical composition of water is H20, and the element hydrogen has an atomic number of 1"
the same as I would interpret:
"The chemical composition of water is H2O.
"The element hydrogen has an atmoic number of 1."
But I will admit I haven't thought this through. So, again, I don't know. You may indeed be right, but can you offer a better explanation?
---------- Post added 05-21-2010 at 06:35 PM ----------
Night Ripper,
Because my last post to you was inconsistent, it leads me to believe "This sentence expresses a proposition" does not in fact express a proposition. But, I will take more time to think it through. Sorry for the confusion.