@xris,
xris wrote:What is this obsession to reinvent god because the old gods failed the test of logic...
Haha, I love this question/statement and I too, in frustration, have asked myself that. Why do people do this?
I haven't any answer; not even for myself. But what the resolution that I've come to is that it seems to be fashionable to say god:
- "... is everything"
- "... is in all of us"
- "... exists as pure energy in all places"
- "... is whatever you conceive it to be"
- "... is something I won't even give you my definition of"
- "... is pure light!"
- "... is the grace shown in mathematics, physics and the unity of the universe!"
And all these - not even presented as euphemisms! These kinds of lofty-no-substance definitions give this
thing no value whatsoever. It's almost as if many of the fine, intelligent people who write here about this concept almost
know in the back of their minds how absurd it is. Yet, they cling, as if somehow this self-deception is a good thing. But then I see this next statement; one I was VERY happy to see:
alex717 wrote:... just ask yourself this, do you like the thought of you dying and becoming nothing? Or would you rather want to go to a place of paradise and be with loved ones...
It's brutal honesty, and he/she needs a hundred cookies and a copy of the
Philosophy Forum Home-Game for this. It's something I think very few have the courage to say. In a sense, it says, "who cares whether or not its
true, I
choose to believe". Now, I don't think this is a good idea - at all - but it speaks volumes about the emotional need so many humans have. It doesn't matter how silly, absurd, murky or pointless the concept is (as a whole), the human heart asserts itself and
reaches out for something.
To my mind one is happier, healthier, more peaceful, more compassionate once this whole silliness is shed. I can understand the desire to believe in "something"; but to me that does not make it (and such can be very painful and terrifying at first, given how we've been socialized). In the end equation, we all must do what our heart bids, no matter how it looks to others.
Nice point; kudos to the both of ya's