1. Philosophy Forum
  2. » Logic
  3. » Intransitive...Irreflexive...

Get Email Updates Email this Topic Print this Page

Reply Sat 5 Dec, 2009 07:39 pm
Hi there.

I need to show by tableau method that an intransitive relation is also irreflexive.

Here is what I know:

-an intransitive relation basically explains the scenario wherein object1 is connected to objected2, and object 2 is connected to object3, but that object 1 is not connected to object3

For example, x is the father of y, and y is the father of z, but x is not the father of z

-in the case of irreflexivity, I think this means that if x and y stand for men, "Rxy," will mean that "x is the father of y." The way I understand "irreflivity" is that when not element is set in relation to in the case of the example I provided above, I know that all intransitive relations are irreflexive, but I am not sure how to go about showing this by tableau.

I think I would be working with something to the effect of...

x∀y∀z is not Rxz
x∀y∀z[Rxy ^ Ryz]
Horace phil
Reply Sun 6 Dec, 2009 04:55 pm
@Horace phil,
I start with this, right?

---------- Post added 12-06-2009 at 08:37 PM ----------

I've been doing some more thinking.

For the relation to be non-transitive all we need is 1 case where Rxy ^ Ryz > notRxz

so this would be read as:

ExEyEz (Rxy ^ Ryz > not Rxz)

For the relation to be non-reflexive , it must be that there is at least one case where Rww (or could I write this as Rxx) is not true


So we get:

ExEyEz (Rxy ^ Ryz > Rxz) > Ew(notRww)

Before when I said AxnotRxx what I was saying was that every x fails to be reflexive, but i think all we need to do is show simply once cause where it fails...

I'm just trying to figure this stuff out.
Reply Tue 22 Mar, 2011 05:42 pm
@Horace phil,
Hey Horace.. I know you havent used this forum for a while, but if you still get this message, can you message me? I need some help with philosophy. My email is [email protected]. Thx i would really appreciate it!

  1. Philosophy Forum
  2. » Logic
  3. » Intransitive...Irreflexive...
Copyright © 2020 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.02 seconds on 07/05/2020 at 05:31:47