@sometime sun,
sometime sun;160882 wrote:Of course it will improve posts, if you want to be publised and part of the mag you had better up your game.
And on a side note, i am a little tried of people complaining that the posts here are not 'good' enough or that people here are not good enough, what is wrong with you? either aid them to be better or stop complaining.
I know lets wave a magic wand and make everyone as talented as you are.
Life would be pretty boring if we were all the same.
Quite frankly it is all about new partiscipation and getting new members interested and them not being afriad of judgements such 'not good enough', when for all we know it might not be just the person who had written something but the people who are reading it.
Be bloody grateful there are people here at all.
I didn't complain. I guess I think that people who make mistakes in philosophy (as anywhere else) can be helped by having their mistakes pointed out to them in a clear way, and even suggesting how to rectify those mistakes. I suppose, too, that suggestions like learning some logic are helpful, particularly when they are followed. If I can get people to realize, and act on the realization that although some basic understanding of logic is not a sufficient condition of decent philosophizing, but that it is certainly a necessary condition of decent philosophizing, I will consider that an important contribution to the success of this forum.
I do know that some quite talented former participants in this forum have been driven off (or nearly so) by what they consider the low quality of discussion on this forum. I, myself, do not agree. This forum is, after all, not dedicated to academic philosophy, and I think that although I understand what those people mean, they should lower their sights. But that cannot mean that we should actually encourage those with low or no standards in philosophy to mob this site. That would obviously be undesirable. It is, after all, not always (or even often) true that more is better. On the contrary. As Spinoza wrote, "All things excellent are as difficult as they are rare; else everyone could accomplish them".