@VideCorSpoon,
Hmmm, jgweed suggested I post here about finding Philosophy of Religion programs. The first thing for you to do, especially since you have been out of school for a bit, is to think about what you want to do in a more specific way. The right program and/or professor will be determined by your own personal goals and what kind of study you want for yourself, i.e., what kind of work you want to be doing, what area of interest you want to work in, etc.
I did my undergraduate work at Columbia U. in New York City, starting in anthropology, then moving to the religion dept. to study philosophy. I went through a process of evaluating whether or not to go into the philosophy dept. or the religion dept. and chose religion since it was much more open and flexible in terms of what I could do. From there, I applied to three schools, all of which had programs that fit what I wanted to do. I ended up at Princeton, which has an incredible religion dept. with top-drawer professors. It's an extremely open program and made up of very generous group of people. Since I really wanted to study philosophy and not so much religion (or even philosophy of religion), it was a good place for me to be, because they were very open and let me do what I wanted within certain, open-ended parameters. It worked out very well for me!
But again, it really depends on what your more specific area of interest is. It's different in grad school than undergrad. You are there for more focused study of your own choosing, and it makes it more important to know a bit about what you want to do beforehand. If you end up in the wrong program for your particular needs, it can make it difficult when you get to the thesis level.
Also, the program entered at Princeton was a Ph.D. program from the outset. I received my M.A. along the way by writing four generals papers, so the process is a bit different than with a M.A. program alone.
So, I don't know if any of that helps you!!! I guess in sum I'd say you need to think first about what kind of program you are looking for, i.e., what it is you want out of it and what you want to study. Do you want a program that is open and flexible, like mine was, or something with more structure that might offer more direct guidance than mine did.
I'd be happy to answer specific questions if you have them!
Alexandria