Get Email Updates • Email this Topic • Print this Page
I will graduate in May with my RN. It will be an Associate Degree of Nursing. I've been debating on whether or not to get my Bachelor's degree in nurisng or not. I just wondered what everyone thought about this and the difference it really makes in working. Is it better if you have a BSN or not? Do you get paid more or what are the pros and cons of having it or not?
I have had my ADN for about 3 years. I have worked with many nurses who are BSN prepared and will have my BSN in 1 year as I have been working on it part time. However, I do not think that BSN nurses are any more prepared than an ADN nurse. The majority of my charge nurses that I worked with in a MAGNET FACILITY were ADN prepared and much easier to work with than some other higher prepared nurses. I do not believe that BSN teaches more critical thinking skills. The additional nurses classes I'm taking for my BSN are related to management and community based nursing. Critical thinking skills are taught the same in ADN and BSN programs. And I know many nurses that believe you don't develop those skills until you have been working anyway. Saying you know how and actually doing so are 2 completely different things. And there were a few BSN prepared nurses that I have worked with that were quite as good with critical thinking and common sense as my ADN coworkers. Oh, and I have been ANCC certified since fall in my field too, so don't think ADN nurses are any less prepared than a BSN nurse.
There are places in the country where you either have to have or be working on you BSN to work as a RN. However, in many states and areas, it makes absolutely no difference as far as pay or job which one you have. What they want is the license thereby passing the NCLEX.
I say work and go back for you BSN when you're ready. I would worry more about orientation and getting settled in your job for the first few months before starting though.
And I have been working on my BSN because I do want my masters, I enjoy education and I have a wonderful support system from my family, especially an uncle, and my friends who think I can do anything I put my mind too.
Obviously, if I was underqualified as a nurse I would not have been able to pass the test
OK, I can't let this one go...I am an ADN educated nurse and must speak up. I have worked 6+ years in emergency medicine with two of those being a charge nurse in a busy Level II trauma center. More letters behind your name and two more years of school do not necessarily teach you critical thinking skills. And as far as being able to save lives, I defibrillated a women, ran TPA, triaged and prioritized multiple patients arriving at the same time (in a small rural hosp with a 6 bed ED) before I was even off orientation. I agree that education is important, but there is also something to be said for a "real life" education. EMT's are taught life saving skills without a four year degree, I've known CNA's and techs with more critical thinking skills than some master's prepared nurses I've known. Just because you have more education does not make you more skilled. We can all take and pass or fail tests, competencies, and certifications. When the chips are down, no one asks you to show your degree before you take care of them. As an ADN, I am not treated any differently by co-workers, facilities, or agencies. I am not paid any less. Bachelor's programs prepare you for management and administrative nursing, but no more clinical nursing than an ADN program. I do not feel you should treat someone better or worse based on their level of education, and I know I would not want a collegue to do this to me or any other nurse.
Skyla, I think that maybe you should take a look at some of the nurses you work with, you may be surprised that some of them are ADN prepared, and you may have never known the difference.
Ginger Snap, amen! More education does not mean more degrees, and just because you passed a test does not prove that you can function under fire! And that's when it really counts because there is a patient depending on you!
Kasey1248, relax and get comfortable with your skills. Settle into your new profession before stressing if you need to go back to school! :wink:
Skyla, I have a BSN and I don't feel threatened by anyone's education (I've taken a few master's level courses). What I have noticed is that our profession has a propensity for attracting people who are achievement-oriented, and can't relax and enjoy what they have now. There's a certain amount of low self esteem going on here ("I'm not good enough without at least a Master's degree, because then I'm JUST A NURSE and no one will take me seriously with those credentials"). All of this is a setup for unrealistic expectations (you do have to have a life outside of your job, it's not all about achieving a certain status). At some point in your life, you have to decide that MORE DEGREES won't buy you career satisfaction, only better performance on the job.
YEAH ADNURSE 1ST!!!!!!! You speak my very mind, and thanks for the EMS plug!! They are so close to my heart given my sister began her nursing career as an EMT (she is a BSN), I began my career as an EMT, my husband is an EMT-I, and I have so many close friends that are EMT's and Paramedics. Give me one of them taking care of me any day!
Skyla, I am not sensitive to "my lack of higher education" as you put it, I am sensitive to someone judging me before they have worked along side me because they assume I am not educated enough. And I do not discourage anyone from attaining a higher degree if that is their ambition. Just do not forget that some of us choose to educate through stepping stones (CNA and/or EMT, LPN, ADN, BSN, MSN, NP), and respect the person for their work, their pt. care, and the person they are, not the letters behind their name. This just proves that nurses still eat their young instead of being supportive and nurturing to each other.
One more point about education. Think about this!
EMS personnel have 2 year degrees and they save lots of lives and are great practioners! Why doesn't this arguement apply to them! I don't hear anyone screaming for them to have huge degrees!
Now who do you want in the field intubating you or your family member?
This big degree thing has elementary education screwed up as far as I'm concerned as well. Do teachers with Master's degrees teaching your Kindergartener make $120,000 a year. It's a sad shame that the only way universities can get people into their schools is to lobby people and come up with studies showing better outcomes with higher and higher degrees. A wise diploma nurse once told me, "When all else fails manipulate the data."
Skyla you have a lot of nerve. I never called you stupid as you have done here to me and I don't think I'm eating my young! You need to look at that finger your pointing because there are 4 more pointing back at you!
Let's just be factual and honest!
I understand about better patient outcomes thorugh evidence-based practice. I know all about it, another term for it is Performance Improvement , and I understand the most recent Bachelor's degree study performed at the UNIVERSITY of Penn, Nursing school. It makes since that there study would say this it supports their school. It's ONE study. If you were in a more rural area and one of the ADN schools did a study what do you think there evidence would show!
What cracks me up is that our local University tried to do a 2 year program back in the late 80's they couldn't even get accreditated and were pushed to a BSN program......... So I went to one of the ACCREDITED Assosciate nursing programs in our state! A high rate of nurses couldn't even pass the boards from our 4 year program. I don't think you realize how it is that BSN programs came into existence.
I think the problem your dealing with is Demographics I live in a more rural area than you in Georgia and you can pretty much count on one hand how many Universities we have and only one University in the state has a nursing program. Where I live it does not require you to have a 4 year degree to work on computers. My uncle has a 2 year degree and works at GORMAN - you know the GPS and night vision people! I aslo have a friend with a 2 year degree who works for Symantecs(you know your Antivirus software- Norton, well and most every software that's not owned by MS) and they're not janitors, either! Speaking of computers and Microsoft did you know that Bill Gates never attended college and has a very successful business??? Not all of us live in big cities!
You are the one who brought up how dim you think ADN nurses are because of our lack of degree and your personal experience with some nurses and I think this pissed off a few of us so-called undereducated. nurses. The nurse who trained me in ICU is our resident cardiac expert has a ADN the doctors look to her for consults, she wrote a book on EKG interprettation. I just can't believe that a nurse in his day an age with your education would would have such and UNDIVERSE or bias view of their peers. Alos Docs go to school for 12 years so they can tell you the nurse what to do! That's why they get paid the REALLY big bucks!
Skyla, I almost think you work for the AACN, maybe your a MAGNET surveyor. I personally feel that the BENNER MODEL OF nursing is an excellent model it's based upon experience and skill not just education alone! I'm all about furthering education.
Again Kasey you can come work with me any time! I'd be gald to work with you! I'm degree neutral a good nurse is a good nurse no matter how you slice them! DO what's best for you and the path you want to run, because as far as I can see there is no end to this nursing shortage. You'll always find a job - You are a nurse. Be very proud of your ADN, you worked equally as hard for it and you have the ability to be as good if not better.